The Third Division team didn't have any City players in it. Plymouth's Romain Larrieu was named as the 'keeper, with his team-mates Graham Coughlan and Paul Watton in defence alongside Cheltenham's Mike Duff and Luton's Matthew Taylor.
Scunthorpe pair Lee Hodges and Peter Beagrie were in the midfield, as were Plymouth playmaker David Friio and Mansfield winger Lee Williamson.
Forwards Nathan Ellington - who left Bristol Rovers for Wigan on transfer deadline day - and Chris Greenacre - the league's top scorer this year - completed the line-up.
Meanwhile, Man Utd striker Ruud Van Nistelrooy took home the PFA Player of the Year trophy, while Newcastle's Craig Bellamy was named the Young Player of the Year.
Don't forget to vote for your Hull City Online Player of the Year. Everyone who votes goes into the free draw, with a copy of the best-selling football game Championship Manager among the prizes up for grabs. Click here to find out more.